SHIPS FROM THE WEST

Kearney concludes his remarkable and sophisticated Monarchies of God sequence with "Ships from the West." Newcomers to this expansive saga should certainly begin with the preceding four volumes, as understanding the narrative hinges on prior knowledge. This installment delivers a satisfying resolution to the overarching story. The series’ signature strengths—rich character development, intricate plotting, and a grounded, thoughtful approach to fantasy—are all on display, resembling fantasy reimagined as historical fiction.

Some readers have voiced concerns regarding character deaths and unanswered plot points, notably Bardolin's alliance with the Himerians. However, we believe these elements elevate the book, contributing to its mature tone. The tragic circumstances demand significant losses, and the deaths of beloved figures underscore the scale of the catastrophe. Even seemingly unheroic ends serve to highlight the brutal realities of war.

Regarding unresolved questions, perceptive readers can likely deduce the motivations behind key decisions. Often, implication and nuance surpass explicit exposition. Our primary criticism lies in the narrative’s rushed pacing; the events deserved considerably more space to unfold. Perhaps the author, nearing the end of a lengthy project, felt compelled to swiftly reach the conclusion, a slight drawback but not a fatal one.